Seven AI Unicorns. One Investment.

Discover the new standard for venture investing. Introducing The Standard Fund, seven sought-after pre-IPO AI companies packaged into a single institutional-grade fund.

Can a Taxable Account Beat a 401(k)?

Christine Benz of Morningstar
October 07, 2025

Being advised to max out your 401(k)is Personal Finance 101. But is that universally solid guidance?

Tax-sheltered retirement plans offer the convenience of automatic investments and tax breaks--pretax contributions and tax-deferred compounding for traditional 401(k)s and tax-free compounding and withdrawals for Roth contributions.

But the availability and quality of the 401(k) are also important considerations.

Some workers don't have access to an employer-provided retirement plan, and 401(k) quality can be uneven. High administrative costs, meager employer matching contributions, and costly investment lineups can detract from 401(k)s' tax-saving features.

Meanwhile, the tax efficiency for investors' nonretirement accounts has improved over the years.

Broad market equity exchange-traded funds have dramatically reduced the tax drag for taxable accountholders, effectively simulating the tax deferral that comes with investing in a 401(k). And many robo-advisors use other techniques to reduce the tax drag on investors' taxable accounts--specifically, selling losing positions to offset gainers elsewhere in investors' portfolios. That can reduce the capital gains taxes on positions when they're eventually liquidated.

Even as investing in a taxable account has grown more attractive, it's a given that investors should put enough in a 401(k)--even a poor one--to earn matching contributions. If the 401(k) plan is weak and they have additional retirement assets to invest, they should opt for an IRA in lieu of steering more money to the poor 401(k) plan. Income limits apply to IRA contributions, but anyone can invest in a Roth IRA through the "backdoor," provided they have earned income to cover the contribution amount.

Multiple Factors Determine Whether a Taxable Account Can Beat a 401(k)

But what if they have additional retirement assets to invest? Once the IRA is fully funded, would those dollars be better off in a weak 401(k) or in a brokerage account held outside a tax-sheltered account?

The answer here, as with so many financial questions, depends on a couple of key factors, especially the following:

    1. 401(k) plan quality: How bad is the plan? Does it have high administrative costs and subpar and/or expensive investment options? Or is it simply that the lineup includes some lackluster funds that are past their prime? Comparing your plan to others can help you make that assessment.

    2. The quality and tax efficiency of the investments in the taxable accounts: Investing in a taxable account will rarely be the better option unless you can invest in securities that make few ongoing distributions of income, capital gains, or both. The good news is that investors can opt for a brokerage platform that offers a good array of low-cost, tax-efficient options--namely, index-tracking ETFs and municipal-bond funds.

    3. The investor's tax bracket at the time of the contributions: Being able to make pretax contributions--as is the case with traditional 401(k)s--will be more valuable to the investor who's in a high tax bracket at the time of that contribution than it will be to the person who's in a lower tax bracket.

    4. The tax bracket at the time of withdrawals: Withdrawals from taxable accounts receive more favorable (and flexible) tax treatment than withdrawals from traditional 401(k)s. Investors pulling from their taxable accounts will owe capital gains taxes, whereas money coming out of a traditional 401(k) is taxed at the investor's ordinary income tax rate, which is higher. Moreover, because the 401(k) money has never been taxed, investors owe taxes on the entire withdrawal, not just the appreciation; taxable-account investors, by contrast, will only owe tax on their gains. Finally, 401(k) assets are subject to required minimum distributions at age 73. For investors who expect to be in a high tax bracket upon retirement, having assets in a taxable account--and enjoying more favorable taxation on the distributions--will be particularly beneficial. (Of course, Roth 401(k) withdrawals are more favorable still: Roth 401(k) assets can be rolled over to a Roth IRA to avoid RMDs. Better still, qualified withdrawals from Roth 401(k)s and IRAs are tax-free.)

Taxable Account vs. 401(k) Takeaways

Investors would do well to weigh their own personal tax situations--both current and future--as well as the quality of their 401(k)s when determining which account types to fund. Investors can also benefit from tax diversification--splitting assets across accounts with varying tax treatment, whether tax-deferred, taxable, or Roth--when saving for retirement.

___

This article was provided to The Associated Press by Morningstar. For more personal finance content, go to https://www.morningstar.com/personal-finance

Christine Benz is Morningstar's director of personal finance and retirement planning.

Continue Reading...

Popular

Five 2026 vehicles you should absolutely wait for

Don’t buy that new car yet. If you can wait, you’ll have new 2026 model year options that aren’t out yet. Although some models barely change, others are completely redesigned and often get the latest features and improvements. Whether you’re interested in improved fuel economy, cutting-edge technology, or maybe just fresh and distinctive styling, there’s likely a car on the horizon that you’ll be interested in. To ensure you don’t miss out on the latest and greatest, the car experts at Edmunds highlight five vehicles you should consider waiting for.

Trump's $300 Million White House Ballroom Could Soon Bear A Very Familiar Name

President Donald Trump is reportedly planning to name his new $300 million White House ballroom after himself.

How It's Possible to Rake in Huge Gains From Gold's Surge - Ad

Gold blasted past $4,300 recently. It's up almost 50% in the past year. But why settle for 50% like most coin buyers... when past gold cycles have thrown off gains of 2,300%, 7,746%, even 9,850%? Weiss Ratings' gold expert Sean Broderick reveals what he believes is a more profitable way to play this surge. No futures, no options, no vault required.

Cathie Wood Dumps $3.7 Million Of Palantir Stock Despite AI Boom — Here's What She's Buying Instead

Ark Invest boosted positions in Qualcomm and BYD, while trimming Palantir and Shopify. Ark also acquired shares of China's BYD despite recent recall.

The New Gold Trade Dominating in Wall Street - Ad

According to Dr. David Eifrig, the gold bull run is just getting started. He says you should move your money to his No. 1 gold stock immediately (not a miner or ETF but it has 1,000% upside potential.) Dr. Eifrig is no stranger to moments like this... As a former Goldman Sachs Vice President, he has traded profitably through just about every stock market situation, that's why his latest gold alert deserves your attention.

Bloom Energy Stock Surges Nearly 17% In Wednesday Pre-Market: What's Going On?

Shares of Bloom Energy Corp soared 18.68% in pre-market trading on Wednesday as third-quarter results surpassed analyst estimates.

Shaquille O'Neal's $180,000 Range Rover Stolen in Suspected Hacker Heist

The custom Range Rover belonging to Shaquille O'Neal has been stolen, reportedly due to a cyber attack.

The $20 Move Giving You Exposure to 2 Ounces of Pure Gold (Worth About $8,000 Today) - Ad

Ex-Goldman Sachs VP reveals a secret of the rich and connected that lets you tap into the upside of a huge amount of real, physical gold for just about twenty dollars at a time. He says the upside could be 1,000% in the coming future.

Monkey escape in Mississippi gives a glimpse into the secretive world of animal research

The recent escape of several research monkeys after the truck carrying them is the latest glimpse into the secretive industry of animal research and the processes that allow key details of what happened to be kept from the public.

This Backdoor Energy Play Beat Gold by 15X - Ad

Gold has hit all-time highs, but one little-known energy play has seen 15x the return since the start of this year. It's all thanks to the incredible energy demands AI is putting on our country. It's a bull market hiding in plain sight, and 40-year Wall Street veteran Larry Benedict has found one company at the heart of it all.

Why Is Trump Memecoin Soaring As Bitcoin, Ethereum Tumble?

The Official Trump (CRYPTO: TRUMP) memecoin erupted into a double-digit rally on Wednesday amid reports that the project's issuer is in talks to buy crowdfunding platform Republic.

Why Is Marlboro-Maker Altria Stock Falling Today?

Altria shares fall as smokeable and oral-tobacco sales slump; revenue dips despite in-line EPS, buyback expansion, and raised 2025 guidance.

Do You Have $500? Here's How to Cash in On Trump's New Deal - Ad

President Trump just proved he's a master dealmaker with this NEW Trump deal... A deal that could help unleash $100 trillion in new wealth. And unlike all his other deals, for the first time ever... Everyday folks like you can cash in on it... starting with just $500.

Elon Musk's SpaceX Shakes Up Bitcoin Market With $133 Million Transfer

SpaceX, the space exploration company led by Elon Musk, has reportedly transferred over $133 million in Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC), causing a stir in the cryptocurrency market.

World's Biggest Multibillionaire Investor Group Is Buying Gold by the Tons - Ad

Most folks have completely missed the fact that there's one group of investors so powerful they're literally buying GOLD by the tons... Stacking it in their locked vaults on pallets in record numbers.

2,000 mink released from Iowa farm in what trade group calls 'terrorist act'

One or more intruders broke into an Iowa mink farm and released 2,000 of the furbearing animals in what a trade group called a “terrorist act” under federal law.

Is Gold About to Replace the Dollar as the World's Reserve Currency? - Ad

Central banks are hoarding gold and dumping the dollar - and one little-known fund is paying out up to 64% a year while the metal climbs. An income expert calls it "the smartest gold play most investors have never heard of."

Trump Reportedly Rebuffs Ukraine Missile Appeal After Putin Call: 'Time To Stop...'

President Donald Trump declined to supply Ukraine with Tomahawk missiles after a tense meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky at the White House on Friday, according to a report.

Dogecoin's $0.21 Problem: Why This Analyst Says Keep It On Your Radar

On Monday, social media influencer Ali Martinez, known popularly on X as Ali, drew the attention of the crypto community to an important resistance level for Dogecoin (CRYPTO: DOGE).

Gold Beats U.S. Treasuries and Could Make Your Income Soar - Ad

While the world's central banks dump America's bonds for gold, one income expert reveals a quiet $15 fund turning that shift into massive monthly income, up to $1,152 every month.

State-run Pakistan International Airlines resumes UK flights after 5-year ban

ISLAMABAD (AP) — State-run Pakistan International Airlines resumed flights to the United Kingdom on Saturday for the first time in five years following the lifting of a ban imposed over a fake pilot license scandal.

Weekend Round-Up: Crypto World Buzzes With Coinbase, Cathie Wood, Melania Trump And Bitcoin News

There was a whirlwind of activity in the cryptocurrency world this week. From optimistic predictions by Coinbase Global Inc. CEO Brian Armstrong to Cathie Wood's backing of a major Ethereum holder, the crypto market was abuzz with news.

Will the "Mar-A-Lago Accord" Cause the Biggest Gold Bull Run in History? - Ad

Gold could soon soar past $27,000 an ounce... as a strange new financial reset, being called "The Mar-a-Lago Accord" rolls out. It's causing insiders to make unprecedented moves... According to one top analyst, you must move YOUR money into his no. 1 gold stock, to secure your wealth and potentially reap massive profits in the process.

Why Did Dragonfly Energy Shares Jump Over 6% After Hours?

Dragonfly Energy Holdings' stock climbed 6.73% after hours to $1.42 following its public offering and strategic updates.

Elizabeth Warren And Adam Schiff Introduce Senate Resolution Condemning Trump's Pardon Of Changpeng Zhao

Senators Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Adam Schiff (D-CA) are introducing a Senate resolution condemning President Donald Trump‘s pardon of Binance (CRYPTO: BNB) founder

Seven AI Unicorns. One Investment. - Ad

Discover the new standard for venture investing. Introducing The Standard Fund, seven sought-after pre-IPO AI companies packaged into a single institutional-grade fund.

Japan's exports and imports grow in September despite Trump's tariffs

TOKYO (AP) — Japan’s exports grew 4.2% in September, according to government data Wednesday, on robust shipments to Asia that offset a decline in exports to the U.S., which were impacted by President Donald Trump’s tariffs.

Firefighters contain blaze at Hungary's main oil refinery

BUDAPEST, Hungary (AP) — Firefighters in have contained a blaze that broke out overnight at the country’s main oil refinery, authorities and Hungarian energy company MOL said Tuesday. No injuries have been reported.

How It's Possible to Rake in Huge Gains From Gold's Surge - Ad

Gold blasted past $4,300 recently. It's up almost 50% in the past year. But why settle for 50% like most coin buyers... when past gold cycles have thrown off gains of 2,300%, 7,746%, even 9,850%? Weiss Ratings' gold expert Sean Broderick reveals what he believes is a more profitable way to play this surge. No futures, no options, no vault required.

Jeff Bezos-Backed Anthropic Projects To Nearly Triple Revenues By 2026: Report

Anthropic, the artificial intelligence (AI) startup, backed by Alphabet's (NASDAQ: GOOGL) (NASDAQ: GOOG) Google and Amazon.com (NASDAQ: AMZN), is reportedly projecting to more than double and potentially nearly triple its annualized revenue run rate next year.

The New Gold Trade Dominating in Wall Street - Ad

According to Dr. David Eifrig, the gold bull run is just getting started. He says you should move your money to his No. 1 gold stock immediately (not a miner or ETF but it has 1,000% upside potential.) Dr. Eifrig is no stranger to moments like this... As a former Goldman Sachs Vice President, he has traded profitably through just about every stock market situation, that's why his latest gold alert deserves your attention.

Instacart Powers Grubhub's Grocery Blitz Across America

Grubhub taps Instacart for nationwide grocery ordering, with Instacart fulfillment, pharmacy additions coming, and promos boosting adoption despite CART dip.

TotalEnergies Profit Outlook Brightens On Refining Strength

TotalEnergies (NYSE: TTE) expects 3Q25 performance to improve with 4% Y/Y increase in oil & gas production.

The $20 Move Giving You Exposure to 2 Ounces of Pure Gold (Worth About $8,000 Today) - Ad

Ex-Goldman Sachs VP reveals a secret of the rich and connected that lets you tap into the upside of a huge amount of real, physical gold for just about twenty dollars at a time. He says the upside could be 1,000% in the coming future.

NFL owners approve sale of 10% of the New York Giants to Julia Koch and her family

NEW YORK (AP) — NFL owners voted to approve the to Julia Koch and her family, Commissioner Roger Goodell said Wednesday.

Trending Now

Information, charts or examples are for illustration and educational purposes only and not for individualized investment management This message contains commercial elements, such as advertising. We only send these offers to those who have opted in to our newsletter. Past performance is not indicative of future results. For these reasons we strongly suggest trading in a DEMO/Simulated account. The information provided by us is for educational and informational purposes only. We make no representations or warranties concerning the products, practices or procedures of any company or entity mentioned or recommended and have not determined if the statements and opinions of the advertiser are accurate, correct or truthful. If you use, act upon or make decisions in reliance on information contained or any external source linked within it, you do so at your own peril and agree to hold us, our officers, directors, shareholders, affiliates and agents without fault.

Copyright markethundred.com
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service