PayPal, Bill Holdings Downgraded As Analyst 'Loses Confidence'

Anusuya Lahiri

April 17, 2025

On Thursday, Seaport Global analyst Jeff Cantwell downgraded two companies -- PayPal Holdings (NASDAQ:PYPL) and Bill Holdings (NYSE:BILL) -- as he has lost confidence that either will eventually meet their previously stated guidance in this new paradigm.

PayPal went from Neutral to Sell and Bill went from Buy to Neutral.

What Happened: Cantwell adjusted his numbers and price targets lower across the board in Fintech ahead of earnings. This reflects how this new, emerging ‘tariff-heavy’ paradigm will eventually impact names under his coverage.

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell also signals that the Fed can’t help, at least not yet. Therefore, most of the adjustments to his numbers also hone in on the back half of fiscal 2025 and 2026.

While first-quarter results should be benign, Cantwell now expects consumer and business spending to eventually start to slow in response to the tariffs’ disruptive effect, likely by the summer months at the latest.

Also Read: PayPal Transaction Margins and Payment Volume Drive Growth, Eyes 2025 Growth With Strong TMD Ahead of Investor Day: Analyst

Why It Matters: The analyst predicts PayPal will struggle to meet its medium-term guidance at Investor Day. Cantwell projected fiscal 2025 revenue of $32.68 billion and EPS of $4.95.

For Bill, he noted the downside to its guide of 20% core revenue growth in fiscal 2026.

For both companies, his updated forecasts are now below consensus.

Regarding the stocks, Fintech has been selling off in recent weeks, and valuations again look fairly reasonable at 3.9 times NTM EV/Sales, 10.9 times EV/EBITDA, and 17.9 times EPS (all medians).

Given that first-quarter results generally reflect a positive fundamental backdrop for Fintech, Cantwell noted investors could see a near-term rebound (‘relief rally’). However, given his expectation for heightened stock volatility and downside risk to consensus EPS in the near term, he noted investors should be prudent/selective buyers.

For Bill, Cantwell projected fiscal 2025 revenue of $1.45 billion and EPS of $1.93.

Price Actions: PayPal stock is up by 0.85% at $60.76 at last check Thursday. Bill is down 1.88%.

Read Next:

Amex CEO Says Consumers Still Spending Freely: So Why Is the Stock Sliding?

Image: Shutterstock

Recommended

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts... - Ad

Elon's New Device Could Launch Biggest IPO of the Decade - Ad

The AI Arms Race Could Send This Obscure Firm Soaring - Ad

The U.S. corporate sector is experiencing a significant surge in earnings, with the growth rate hitting a four-year high despite concerns over the impact of the trade war initiated by President Donald Trump.

Marjorie Taylor Greene Buys Blue Chip Stock Near 52-Week Low

Marjorie Taylor Greene is known for buying multiple stocks at a time, based on recent disclosures. A new filing shows one stock bought in November.

Better Than Bitcoin? (Top Crypto for Less Than $1)

Better Than Bitcoin? (Top Crypto for Less Than $1) - Ad

Over the past 15 years, Bitcoin has outperformed stocks, bonds, and every other asset you could've bought. 2025 is already shaping up to be another banner year, with Bitcoin recently hitting a new all-time high. But there's a better way to profit from this new crypto rally. Most people don't know about it... and yet it's returned over 1,000% in 4 months. This could be the #1 way to invest in crypto right now.

Trump Unveils $200 Billion Trade Deal With Switzerland And Liechtenstein To Cull $38.5 Billion US Goods Deficit By 2028

President Donald Trump announced a framework for a trade deal with Switzerland and Liechtenstein on Friday.

Schwab: Half Of US Investors May Ditch Other Assets For ETFs — 4 Funds To Watch

Nearly half of ETF investors could go all-ETF within five years, Schwab says. Here's how they're building portfolios with funds like ITOT, BND, and XLK.

Trump Signs Law to Launch Dollar 2.0

Trump Signs Law to Launch Dollar 2.0 - Ad

Trump just signed law S.1582, unleashing the biggest money shift in 100+ years. For the first time since 1913, private firms - not the Fed - can mint a "Dollar 2.0." Treasury says it could drain $6.6T from banks and pay 10X current savings rates. Early investors in minting firms could see 40X returns by 2032.

Low-Risk DeFi or TradFi Trojan Horse? The Fight For Crypto's Soul

Snapshot: Vitalik Buterin's push for structural risk minimization in DeFi aims to make decentralized finance safer and more sustainable, but critics warn it could neuter Ethereum's growth and turn crypto into compliant, on-chain TradFi. Skeptics from across the ecosystem argue true safety is impossible without sa

Zohran Mamdani Says No More Thanking Veterans Today, Forgetting Tomorrow — Trump, Obama And Others Express Gratitude For Service

America's top political and tech leaders — including Donald Trump, Barack Obama, Tim Cook, and Sundar Pichai — marked Veterans Day 2025 with tributes honoring the courage and sacrifice of U.S. service members.

Buy This Gold Stock Before the New Year

Buy This Gold Stock Before the New Year - Ad

America is about to see a massive shift in how regular people buy and store gold. Next year, the world's largest gold buyer is expected to launch a new way for everyday Americans to invest in gold with a simple tap on their phone - and it could go live in 2026. When it does, a tiny gold stock trading around $1.60 could explode.

Why Is Phio Pharmaceuticals Stock Soaring Today?

Shares of Phio Pharmaceuticals Corp. (NASDAQ: PHIO) are rising Monday after the company provided an update on an ongoing medical trial.

Jim Cramer: Chipotle Is 'Too Expensive,' Buy This Plane Maker

On "Mad Money," Cramer discusses Henry Schein, Bloom Energy, Tyler Technologies, Boeing and Chipotle Mexican Grill.

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare?

Is This Elon's Worst Nightmare? - Ad

Elon's empire looks doomed - crashing sales, lost tax credits, and media backlash. But behind the scenes, Tesla is about to unleash a breakthrough Forbes calls a "multi-trillion-dollar opportunity." It's not the end - it's the start of a 25,000% AI comeback.

Rand Paul Warns Of 'Farmageddon' As Tariffs Hit Farmers, Says Supreme Court Must Rein In Trump's Executive Tax Power

Sen. Rand Paul issued a warning about the impact of tariffs on farmers, calling them an unconstitutional exercise of presidential power.

UPS cargo plane with 3 aboard explodes on takeoff at Louisville airport, igniting huge fire

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (AP) — A large UPS cargo plane with three people aboard crashed Tuesday while taking off from an airport in Louisville, Kentucky, igniting an explosion and massive fire that left a thick plume of black smoke over the area.

Nvidia CEO: E.I. Will Be as Common as Cars Today

Nvidia CEO: E.I. Will Be as Common as Cars Today - Ad

E.I. isn't science fiction anymore. It's already here. And one little-known company is quietly supplying the systems behind it. This stock is still under Wall Street's radar... but not for long. You'll get the name, the ticker, and the full thesis inside.

Average US long-term mortgage rate ticks up to 6.22% after four straight weekly declines

The average rate on a 30-year U.S. mortgage ticked up for the first time in five weeks after falling to its lowest level in more than a year last week.

Some Social Security Recipients Won't Have To Wait Until 2026 For COLA Hike

Social Security and SSI recipients will receive a 2.8% cost-of-living adjustment in 2026, with SSI beneficiaries seeing the increase a day earlier due to a federal holiday.

Investing Legend Hints the End May Be Near for These 3 Iconic Stocks

Investing Legend Hints the End May Be Near for These 3 Iconic Stocks - Ad

Futurist Eric Fry say Amazon, Tesla and Nvidia are all on the verge of major disruption. To help protect anyone with money invested in them, he's sharing three exciting stocks to replace them with. He gives away the names and tickers completely free in his brand-new "Sell This, Buy That" broadcast.

Peter Thiel Once Explained Why Bitcoin Won't Go Up 'Dramatically' And How It's Set For A 'Volatile, Bumpy Ride' Thanks To BlackRock

Bitcoin's ongoing struggles have brought renewed attention to comments made last year by Palantir Technologies co-founder Peter Thiel, who predicted that the leading cryptocurrency was unlikely to see a dramatic surge

Pizza Hut's parent company says it's considering selling the chain

Pizza Hut could soon be up for sale.

We've Seen This Before... and It Didn't End Well

We've Seen This Before... and It Didn't End Well - Ad

Strange events are unfolding in the global financial system. A monetary reset dubbed the "Mar-a-Lago Accord" is quietly in motion, and the financial elite are already taking protective action. If history is any guide, you could lose up to 40% of your wealth in the next two years. Move your money before it's too late.

TSLA, PLTR, IREN And More: 5 Stocks That Dominated Investor Buzz This Week

Retail investors talked up five hot stocks this week (Nov. 3–7) on X and Reddit's r/WallStreetBets: TSLA, PLTR, MSTR, AMD, IREN.

Benzinga Bulls And Bears: Nvidia, Webull, Netflix — And Tech Stocks Face Worst Sell-Off Since April

Benzinga examined the prospects for many investors' favorite stocks over the last week — here's a look at some of our top stories.

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts...

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts... - Ad

George Gilder - who predicted the iPhone 17 years early and gave Reagan the first microchip - is making his boldest call yet. He says an American nanotech "super-convergence" could mint more millionaires than any event in recent memory. He's found 3 stocks set to benefit the most.

Anthony Scaramucci Calls Zohran Mamdani's Win An 'Anger-Based Reaction' To Boomer Policies, Says New NYC Mayor Could Become 'Popular' If...

Anthony Scaramucci, the founder of SkyBridge Capital, described Zohran Mamdani’s victory in New York City's mayoral race as an “anger-based reaction” by the young people against the policies of the boomer generation's political elites.

IREN Skyrockets After Sealing $9.7 Billion AI Cloud Deal With Microsoft

Pre-market trading sees IREN shares up after securing $9.7B cloud contract with Microsoft, partnering with Dell.

Elon's New Device Could Launch Biggest IPO of the Decade

Elon's New Device Could Launch Biggest IPO of the Decade - Ad

Elon Musk's new device is being called a "game-changer"-and even the White House is using this tech. Jeff Brown says it could launch Musk's next trillion-dollar company and make early investors rich. You can claim a stake now for as little as $500.

Centrus Energy Stock Slides After Q3 Revenues Miss Estimates

Here's a look at the Q3 earnings report from Centrus Energy.

Trump's $2,000 Dividend Check Plan, $200 Billion Trade Deal And More: This Week In Economy

Weekend roundup: Key Trump economic moves, trade deals, and market forecasts dominated the news.

The AI Arms Race Could Send This Obscure Firm Soaring

The AI Arms Race Could Send This Obscure Firm Soaring - Ad

The AI arms race could be a massive boom to ONE company that's doing something truly unprecedented. Its new device could become the cornerstone of the next wave of the AI revolution... And early investors could make a substantial sum of money as this story hits the mainstream.

What to know about 10% reduction in flights at U.S. airports caused by the government shutdown

NEW YORK (AP) — are among those facing 10% reductions in air traffic Friday due to the .

Donald Trump's Popularity Falls As Shutdown Drags On

President Donald Trump's approval rating has continued to drop, with the latest poll showing a significant decline, raising concerns for the Republican Party as the 2026 midterm elections approach.

Better Than Bitcoin? (Top Crypto for Less Than $1)

Better Than Bitcoin? (Top Crypto for Less Than $1) - Ad

Cathie Wood Goes All-In On Peter Thiel's Crypto Play Bullish With Back-To-Back Million-Dollar Buys

Cathie Wood-led Ark Invest purchased shares in Bullish, a crypto exchange backed by Peter Thiel, through three of its funds. Other key trades were also made, including buying shares in CRISPR and Beam Therapeutics.

Cathie Wood Makes $13.4 Million Bet On This Social Network After Earnings Crash — But Dumps Robinhood And Reddit

Ark Invest made significant trades, focusing on Pinterest, Robinhood, and Reddit amid earnings reports. They have confidence in Pinterest's potential despite recent setbacks.

Trump Signs Law to Launch Dollar 2.0

Trump Signs Law to Launch Dollar 2.0 - Ad

Trump's 50-Year Mortgage Plan, Sanders Critiques Musk, Trump Backs Crypto And More: This Week In Politics

Weekend headlines: Trump's 50-year mortgage plan, Sanders criticizes Musk, Trump backs crypto, Scaramucci on NYC mayor, Mamdani challenges Trump.

Teradyne, Wayfair, And Illumina Are Among the Top 10 Large-Cap Gainers Last Week (Oct. 27-Oct. 31): Are the Others in Your Portfolio?

Top weekly large-cap gainers included Teradyne, Wayfair, Illumina, Guardant Health, ASE, C.H. Robinson, Lumen, Symbotic, Credo, YPF after strong results.

Buy This Gold Stock Before the New Year

Buy This Gold Stock Before the New Year - Ad

Bitcoin's Crash Below $100,000 Isn't The End: Wall Street Vet Says: 'We Have To Get Through This'

For the first time since July, Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) fell below $100,000 on Tuesday as the crypto sell-off saw $1.7 billion in liquidations in 24 hours.

Trending Now