PayPal, Bill Holdings Downgraded As Analyst 'Loses Confidence'

Anusuya Lahiri

April 17, 2025

On Thursday, Seaport Global analyst Jeff Cantwell downgraded two companies -- PayPal Holdings (NASDAQ:PYPL) and Bill Holdings (NYSE:BILL) -- as he has lost confidence that either will eventually meet their previously stated guidance in this new paradigm.

PayPal went from Neutral to Sell and Bill went from Buy to Neutral.

What Happened: Cantwell adjusted his numbers and price targets lower across the board in Fintech ahead of earnings. This reflects how this new, emerging ‘tariff-heavy’ paradigm will eventually impact names under his coverage.

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell also signals that the Fed can’t help, at least not yet. Therefore, most of the adjustments to his numbers also hone in on the back half of fiscal 2025 and 2026.

While first-quarter results should be benign, Cantwell now expects consumer and business spending to eventually start to slow in response to the tariffs’ disruptive effect, likely by the summer months at the latest.

Also Read: PayPal Transaction Margins and Payment Volume Drive Growth, Eyes 2025 Growth With Strong TMD Ahead of Investor Day: Analyst

Why It Matters: The analyst predicts PayPal will struggle to meet its medium-term guidance at Investor Day. Cantwell projected fiscal 2025 revenue of $32.68 billion and EPS of $4.95.

For Bill, he noted the downside to its guide of 20% core revenue growth in fiscal 2026.

For both companies, his updated forecasts are now below consensus.

Regarding the stocks, Fintech has been selling off in recent weeks, and valuations again look fairly reasonable at 3.9 times NTM EV/Sales, 10.9 times EV/EBITDA, and 17.9 times EPS (all medians).

Given that first-quarter results generally reflect a positive fundamental backdrop for Fintech, Cantwell noted investors could see a near-term rebound (‘relief rally’). However, given his expectation for heightened stock volatility and downside risk to consensus EPS in the near term, he noted investors should be prudent/selective buyers.

For Bill, Cantwell projected fiscal 2025 revenue of $1.45 billion and EPS of $1.93.

Price Actions: PayPal stock is up by 0.85% at $60.76 at last check Thursday. Bill is down 1.88%.

Read Next:

Amex CEO Says Consumers Still Spending Freely: So Why Is the Stock Sliding?

Image: Shutterstock

Recommended

Urgent Copper Stock With Strong Catalysts - Ad

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts... - Ad

Is Big Pharma's Next Target Already in Play? - Ad

Popular

Ford Expedition vs GMC Yukon, an Edmunds big SUV comparison

Let’s say you need a vehicle with room for more than five passengers, a large cargo area, and the ability to pull a heavy trailer. A full-size three-row SUV should work well, but which one? The most significant news this year is the redesigned . Ford has given its biggest SUV a complete makeover with a more upscale interior, new technology features and a novel split-opening tailgate.

This Inexpensive Tesla Rival Is Quietly Gaining Ground — Key Ranking Suggests A Major Breakout Could Be Imminent

Li Auto surges into the top 10th percentile value ranking, up 1.30 points. Undervalued Tesla rival with moderate growth.

Central Banks Are Buying More Gold Than Ever-And This U.S. Miner Is Ready to Oblige

Central Banks Are Buying More Gold Than Ever-And This U.S. Miner Is Ready to Oblige - Ad

Central banks are rapidly increasing their gold reserves-now nearly 20% of global assets. With rising demand and geopolitical pressure, U.S. gold supply is becoming more strategic than ever.

Japanese game maker Nintendo reports zooming sales and profit on its hit Switch 2 machine

TOKYO (AP) — Japanese video-game maker Nintendo’s net profit jumped 85% in April-September from the year before, as its sales more than doubled following the launch of its hit Switch 2 console in June, the company said Tuesday.

Tempus AI Stock (TEM) Slides 6% Overnight: Here's Why The Stock Is Trending

Tempus AI shares fell 6.02% in after-hours trading Tuesday following its third-quarter earnings report.

From Ore to Gold Bars-This Nevada Mine Is Already Producing

From Ore to Gold Bars-This Nevada Mine Is Already Producing - Ad

Most juniors explore...Few actually produce. This one's already pouring gold thanks to infrastructure that would cost tens of millions to build today. With major land holdings and room to scale, it's one to watch.

Gold prices have tumbled from recent records. What's behind the losses?

NEW YORK (AP) — Less than a day after to another record high, prices for the precious metal plunged — marking the biggest sell-off in years.

Ferrari CEO Confirms Electric Car Plans, Raises Full-Year Outlook

Ferrari N.V. stock rose after reporting Q3 results and guidance. Sales grew 7.4% and EPS beat estimates. Net revenues and adjusted EPS outlook raised.

A Tiny Biotech Just Posted 10× Stronger Cancer Results

A Tiny Biotech Just Posted 10× Stronger Cancer Results - Ad

Early studies show this breakthrough delivery platform would make cancer treatments safer and more powerful. Now, with Big Pharma watching closely, investors are starting to take notice of what could be the next major biotech story.

Trump Defends Missile Strike On 'Drug-Carrying' Submarine Amid Human Rights Outcry

Trump defends strike on drug sub, says it targeted fentanyl-laden vessel heading to US. Two survivors were rescued.

San Francisco mayor proposes denser housing to tackle affordability crisis

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie is trying to get more homes built for people like Liam Murphy: a fifth-generation city kid who found himself repeatedly outbid for tiny two-bedroom houses that wound up selling for $1.6 million.

Why Are 21 Billionaires Moving Their Money ASAP?

Why Are 21 Billionaires Moving Their Money ASAP? - Ad

One of the biggest stock market events in 25 years is rapidly unfolding... The economist who predicted the 2008 Financial Crisis says it will be: "The Biggest Crash of Our Lifetime." Starting November 19 it could cut the entire tech marketing by HALF.

UPS cargo plane with 3 aboard explodes on takeoff at Louisville airport, igniting huge fire

LOUISVILLE, Ky. (AP) — A large UPS cargo plane with three people aboard crashed Tuesday while taking off from an airport in Louisville, Kentucky, igniting an explosion and massive fire that left a thick plume of black smoke over the area.

Shaquille O'Neal's $180,000 Range Rover Stolen in Suspected Hacker Heist

The custom Range Rover belonging to Shaquille O'Neal has been stolen, reportedly due to a cyber attack.

Gold Bars Are Pouring, but This Miner is Still Priced Like a Startup

Gold Bars Are Pouring, but This Miner is Still Priced Like a Startup - Ad

You'd expect a gold miner with production, a full refinery, and big-name investors to be trading at a premium. But this one? It's still under $1

Coeur Mining's $7 Billion Deal For New Gold Creates $20 Billion Powerhouse

Coeur Mining Inc. (CDE) announced acquisition of New Gold Inc. (NGD) in all-stock deal valued at $7 billion.

Why Did MediciNova Stock (MNOV) Jump Over 87% In After-Hours Trading?

MediciNova shares soared over 87% in after-hours trading on Thursday following the publication of promising research.

New Number One Copper Start Alert

New Number One Copper Start Alert - Ad

EVs and AI devour copper. Supply cannot keep up. A Quebec discovery with high grade, infrastructure, and cheap power is funded to drill through the year. Catalysts are lining up. Institutions are circling. Move now while it is still early.

Jim Cramer Warns 'Don't Be Fooled' Because Speculators In Gold, Quantum And Nuclear Energy Aren't Going Down 'Without A Fight'

Former hedge fund manager and renowned CNBC TV host Jim Cramer is sounding the alarm on certain speculative pockets of the market, urging investors to sell into the "snapback" momentum if they haven't already done so.

Donald Trump Jr.-Linked Drone Maker Unusual Machines Wins Major Pentagon Deal

Unusual Machines secures its largest Pentagon drone contract to date, with Trump Jr. serving as an adviser but not involved in the deal.

The $43B Big Pharma Story is Starting Over-With a New Player

The $43B Big Pharma Story is Starting Over-With a New Player - Ad

Big Pharma once paid $43B for a small biotech with a similar platform. Now, a new company is following that same playbook, leveraging its patented delivery technology to attract partnerships and near-term revenue potential.

Kevin O'Leary Said His Mom's Secret 55-Year-Old Investment Portfolio Outperformed Most Hedge Funds—He Decided Then, 'That's How I'm Going To Invest'

Shark Tank's Kevin O'Leary revealed how his mother's disciplined, 55-year investment strategy of diversification and long-term thinking shaped his own approach to building and preserving wealth.

Trump Reportedly Rebuffs Ukraine Missile Appeal After Putin Call: 'Time To Stop...'

President Donald Trump declined to supply Ukraine with Tomahawk missiles after a tense meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky at the White House on Friday, according to a report.

Urgent Copper Stock With Strong Catalysts

Urgent Copper Stock With Strong Catalysts - Ad

Quebec discovery. Strong grades. Roads and hydro in place. Funding secured for a busy drill calendar. Each assay can build scale and tighten the window for early entries as EVs and data centers pull harder on copper. Do not wait.

After winning Trump's $20 billion, President Milei must win votes as Argentine industry reels

BUENOS AIRES, Argentina (AP) — The factory floor used to roar.

China May Have Made A Breakthrough With Solid State Batteries Offering 600-Mile+ Range, Here's What You Should Know

Chinese researchers' share breakthrough in EV battery technology with solid-state batteries offering 600+ mile range and weighing 220 lbs.

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts...

"Tech Prophet" Who Predicted the iPhone Now Predicts... - Ad

George Gilder - who predicted the iPhone 17 years early and gave Reagan the first microchip - is making his boldest call yet. He says an American nanotech "super-convergence" could mint more millionaires than any event in recent memory. He's found 3 stocks set to benefit before November 18's bombshell.

Looking For The Next Beyond Meat? Here Are The Top 10 Most Shorted Stocks

Here's a look at the most heavily shorted stocks in the market as investors look for the next Beyond Meat.

Stock Market Today: S&P 500, Nasdaq, Dow Jones Futures Rise— Micron, Bitmine, Coinbase In Focus

U.S. stock futures rose on Monday following Friday’s advances. Futures of major benchmark indices were higher.

Is Big Pharma's Next Target Already in Play?

Is Big Pharma's Next Target Already in Play? - Ad

A small biotech may have cracked one of medicine's biggest problems-how to deliver cancer drugs safely and effectively. With patented technology and promising early data, it's already catching the attention of Big Pharma.

Eli Lilly's Oral Weight Loss Drug Shows Superiority Over Two Approved Drugs

Orforglipron meets key endpoints in Phase 3 trials, showing A1C reduction, weight loss, and cardiovascular benefits for type 2 diabetes.

Instacart Powers Grubhub's Grocery Blitz Across America

Grubhub taps Instacart for nationwide grocery ordering, with Instacart fulfillment, pharmacy additions coming, and promos boosting adoption despite CART dip.

Central Banks Are Buying More Gold Than Ever-And This U.S. Miner Is Ready to Oblige

Central Banks Are Buying More Gold Than Ever-And This U.S. Miner Is Ready to Oblige - Ad

Central banks are rapidly increasing their gold reserves-now nearly 20% of global assets. With rising demand and geopolitical pressure, U.S. gold supply is becoming more strategic than ever.

Meta Lures Gen Z Talent With Six-Figure Salaries Amid Shrinking Job Opportunities — Here's How Much It's Offering

Meta is reportedly offering hefty paychecks for entry-level software engineering roles, a move seen as a response to the challenging job market for recent graduates.

Donald Trump Faces 'No Kings Day' Protests As Millions March Nationwide, GOP Stays Silent Amid Authoritarianism Claims

Millions rallied nationwide against Trump, with top lawmakers supporting protests and condemning Trump's consolidation of power.

From Ore to Gold Bars-This Nevada Mine Is Already Producing

From Ore to Gold Bars-This Nevada Mine Is Already Producing - Ad

2,000 mink released from Iowa farm in what trade group calls 'terrorist act'

One or more intruders broke into an Iowa mink farm and released 2,000 of the furbearing animals in what a trade group called a “terrorist act” under federal law.

President Trump returns to '60 Minutes' for first time after settling lawsuit against newsmagazine

President Donald Trump is returning to “60 Minutes” this weekend, his first appearance on the show since he this summer with CBS News over the newsmagazine's with Kamala Harris. Trump was interviewed by CBS' Norah O'Donnell Friday at Mar-a-Lago for the appearance, which will air this Sunday.

A Tiny Biotech Just Posted 10× Stronger Cancer Results

A Tiny Biotech Just Posted 10× Stronger Cancer Results - Ad

Weekend Round-Up: Crypto World Buzzes With Coinbase, Cathie Wood, Melania Trump And Bitcoin News

There was a whirlwind of activity in the cryptocurrency world this week. From optimistic predictions by Coinbase Global Inc. CEO Brian Armstrong to Cathie Wood's backing of a major Ethereum holder, the crypto market was abuzz with news.

Trending Now